Fraud Blocker

Rowing vs. Elliptical Machine: The Ultimate Cardio Face-off

A woman is sitting on an exercise machine in a gym.
Read Time: 8 minutes

Table of Contents

Ah, the age-old debate among fitness enthusiasts: which cardio machine reigns supreme for a full-body workout – the rowing machine or the elliptical? This rivalry has persisted for years, echoing in the corridors of gyms and fitness forums worldwide. The rowing machine and the elliptical are akin to choosing between two celebrated athletes, each with its own legion of ardent followers. Whether you’re new to the world of fitness or a seasoned gym-goer, understanding the nuances of these two machines can greatly benefit your workout regime. Their distinct mechanisms and benefits set them apart in many ways but also share a few similarities. So, let’s dive right in, dissect their features, and see how they stack up against each other!

The Rowing Machine: A Deep Dive

Rowing machines, often simply called “rowers”, have surged in popularity recently. They mimic the motion of rowing a boat. With every pull, you’re engaging your arms, back, legs, and core. That’s pretty much every major muscle group in one fluid motion!

  1. Advantages of the Rowing Machine

    • Full Body Workout: As mentioned, rowing is one of the few exercises that offer a comprehensive full-body workout.
    • Low Impact: Unlike running, rowing is easy on the joints. This makes it an excellent choice for people of all age groups.
    • Calorie Burn: Depending on your intensity, rowing can torch up to 600-800 calories an hour.
  2. Challenges with Rowing

    • Learning Curve: Proper rowing form can take some time to master, but it’s crucial to prevent injuries.
    • Space: Rowers can be quite long, requiring more space compared to some other home gym equipment.

The Elliptical: An Overview

The elliptical trainer, sometimes called a cross-trainer, is a stationary exercise machine that mimics the running motion without the harsh impact on the joints. It’s a staple in most gyms and has its own set of devout followers.

  1. Advantages of the Elliptical

    • Joint Friendly: Much like rowing, the elliptical is low-impact, providing a break for your knees and hips.
    • Upper Body Engagement: Models with moving handles allow for arm engagement, turning a typically lower-body workout into a full-body endeavor.
    • Customization: Most ellipticals come with adjustable resistance and incline settings to tailor your workout.
  2. Challenges with the Elliptical

    • Monotony: Some users find the movement repetitive, which could affect motivation.
    • Calorie Burn: While you can still burn significantly, it might be slightly less than with aggressive rowing.

Rowing vs. Elliptical: An In-depth Comparison

Muscle Engagement:

Both machines are touted for their ability to deliver full-body workouts. However, there are distinct differences in how and which muscles are predominantly targeted.

  1. Rowing Machine:

    • Posterior Chain Engagement: One of the standout features of rowing is its pronounced engagement of the posterior chain, which includes muscles such as the latissimus dorsi (back), glutes, and hamstrings. This makes it particularly beneficial for individuals looking to strengthen these areas.
    • Core Activation: While it might not be immediately obvious, maintaining a proper rowing posture and technique requires significant core activation, particularly the rectus abdominis and obliques.
    • Upper Body Strength: The pulling motion in rowing recruits the biceps, triceps, and shoulders.
  2. Elliptical:

    • Quadriceps and Calves: The elliptical predominantly works the front of the legs, targeting the quadriceps and the calf muscles.
    • Arm Engagement: With handlebars that move back and forth, the elliptical also engages the biceps and triceps, albeit less intensively than rowing.
    • Low Stress on Joints: The elliptical’s fluid motion ensures minimal stress on the joints, making it an excellent choice for those with joint concerns.

Cardio Intensity:

Cardiovascular workouts are pivotal for heart health, endurance, and weight loss. Both machines can be formidable tools in this department.

  1. Rowing Machine:

    • Rapid Heart Rate Increase: Due to its demanding nature, rowing can spike your heart rate swiftly, providing an intense workout in shorter durations.
    • HIIT Suitability: Rowing machines are often favored for high-intensity interval training (HIIT) because of the ease with which intensity can be varied.
  2. Elliptical:

    • Steady-State Cardio: The elliptical shines in steady-state cardio workouts, where you maintain a consistent pace for longer periods.
    • Heart Rate Zones: Many ellipticals come equipped with heart rate monitors, allowing users to stay within specific zones tailored to their fitness goals.

Versatility:

Flexibility in workout options can keep routines fresh and engaging.

  1. Rowing Machine:

    • Varied Workouts: With the possibility of interval training, endurance rows, or power strokes, rowing sessions can be continually varied.
    • Simulation Options: Modern rowers come with simulation settings, letting you experience rowing in different water conditions, from calm lakes to challenging rivers.
  2. Elliptical:

    • Multiple Modes: Apart from standard elliptical motion, some models offer stair-climbing or even hiking simulations.
    • Adjustable Settings: With resistance and incline adjustments, ellipticals can be tailored to mimic uphill workouts or varied terrain.

Space & Portability:

For many, especially those with home gyms, the size and ease of storage of workout equipment are crucial considerations.

  1. Rowing Machine:

    • Compact When Stored: Many modern rowing machines are designed to be stored upright, taking minimal floor space.
    • Weight: While rowers can be hefty, their singular shape often makes them easier to move.
  2. Elliptical:

    • Footprint: Ellipticals tend to have a consistent footprint, which can be relatively compact in modern models.
    • Mobility: Many ellipticals come with wheels on the base, allowing for easier repositioning in a room.

In summary, both the rowing machine and the elliptical offer distinct advantages. Your choice should hinge on your specific fitness goals, available space, and personal preferences. Both are commendable tools in the journey to optimal health. 

Rowing Machine vs. Elliptical: The Great Cardio Debate

Ah, the age-old debate among fitness enthusiasts: which cardio machine reigns supreme for a full-body workout – the rowing machine or the elliptical? This rivalry has persisted for years, echoing in the corridors of gyms and fitness forums worldwide. The rowing machine and the elliptical are akin to choosing between two celebrated athletes, each with its own legion of ardent followers. Whether you’re new to the world of fitness or a seasoned gym-goer, understanding the nuances of these two machines can greatly benefit your workout regime. Their distinct mechanisms and benefits set them apart in many ways but also share a few similarities. So let’s dive right in, dissect their features, and see how they stack up against each other!

Historical Context

To truly appreciate the debate, it’s essential to understand where each machine originates:

  1. Rowing Machine: Rooted in the age-old activity of rowing boats, this machine was designed to simulate the physical effort of watercraft rowing. Its origins trace back to ancient civilizations but became a popular fitness tool in the late 20th century.
  2. Elliptical: A much younger invention, the elliptical trainer, often dubbed as the ‘cross-trainer,’ was developed in the 1990s. Its low-impact motion was revolutionary, providing an effective workout while minimizing joint stress.

Mechanics and Movement

The way each machine operates sets the foundation for their benefits and challenges:

  1. Rowing Machine: It provides a compound movement requiring synchronization between pulling with the arms, extending the legs, and leaning back. This means several muscle groups are activated simultaneously.
  2. Elliptical: With its signature oval motion (hence the name), the elliptical engages both the upper and lower body. Users get a rhythmic, flowing workout by pushing and pulling the handlebars and pedaling.

Training Approach

Each machine offers unique training methods, which cater to different fitness goals:

  1. Rowing Machine: Ideal for interval training, users can alternate between high-intensity sprints and low-intensity recovery periods. This simulates the ebb and flow of actual rowing races.
  2. Elliptical: It excels in both interval training and steady-state cardio, making it versatile. Users can adjust resistance and incline to customize the intensity and target different muscle groups.

Atmosphere & Experience

How you feel while working out can significantly influence your motivation and consistency:

  1. Rowing Machine: The rhythmic pull and release offer a meditative quality. Some advanced machines even have water resistance that mimics the sound and feel of rowing on water, adding an element of tranquility.
  2. Elliptical: It provides a smooth, gliding experience. With the ability to listen to music, watch TV, or read during workouts, it’s perfect for those who like multitasking.

By now, it’s evident that both the rowing machine and the elliptical have their merits. It’s less about one being universally better and more about which is the right fit for individual preferences and goals.

Conclusion

The rowing machine vs. elliptical debate doesn’t have a one-size-fits-all answer. Both have unique benefits and challenges. It’s about aligning the machine’s features with your personal fitness goals. Try both, and listen to your body. Whether you’re rowing through virtual waters or gliding on an elliptical trail, the journey toward a fitter you is what truly counts.

FAQs

1. Which machine is better for beginners?

Both are beginner-friendly, but the elliptical might have a gentler learning curve.

2. Can I lose weight using these machines?

Absolutely! Both machines can be integral parts of a weight loss journey when paired with a balanced diet.

3. Which is more effective for building muscle?

With its intense pull motion and resistance, the rower can be slightly more effective for muscle building.

4. Do these machines strain the back?

Not if used correctly. Proper form is key. If you’re unsure, consider hiring a trainer or watching tutorials.

Editor’s note: The content on Base Strength is meant to be informative in nature, but it shouldn’t take the place of advice and/or supervision from a medical professional. The opinions and articles on this site are not intended for use as diagnosis, prevention, and/or treatment of health problems. Speak with your physician if you have any concerns. Please also see our disclaimers.

Trending Topics

Shopping cart
Sign in

No account yet?

Start typing to see posts you are looking for.
Skip to content